片简拾零 – Telegram
102 subscribers
18 photos
2 files
30 links
一个普通人的频道,借此处理清思绪。见识有限,所言无非皮毛之谈,只是片简拾零、敝帚自珍。
Download Telegram
陈纯现在微博账号也消失了…这一波“揪斗”,看着真的感到很沉重。
奋起反抗压迫、反抗不正义,没问题,但是有条人道底线不能越过,否则抗暴者又会蜕变成新的施暴者,陷入死循环。
Boris Johnson made the first move. The opposition parties may have to try a vote of no confidence before the suspension, so that after the prorogation there will be enough time left for them to pass legislation against a no-deal Brexit should the vote of no confidence fail.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49493632
The bill to block no-deal Brexit on October 31 received royal assent, thus becoming law.

John Bercow, the current Speaker of the House of Commons, announced that he would step down on October 31.

MPs passed a humble address to force the government to release 2 sets of records: all the internal communication messages relating to the prorogation of Parliament; and all the documents relating to Operation Yellowhammer.

The Prime Minister's bid to secure an early general election failed a second time.

Parliament prorogued, after some clamorous scenes in the lower chamber.

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/09/mps-order-johnson-to-hand-over-aides-messages-about-prorogation
再革命也不需上房揭掉自家屋瓦,再“爱国”也不需放弃自己正常无害的娱乐活动。NBA中国赛上海、深圳两场座无虚席,这个现象没有半点值得批评的地方。相反,把参与正常娱乐活动的同胞斥为“跪族”的人,才真正可耻。
Merely a temporary relief for the Remain camp. Since BJ got his new withdrawal agreement back, the Remain camp has been the underdog again. A majority of MPs now are ready to give their ayes to the deal and the momentum to "get Brexit down" is very much there. This vote does not change any of that. As one journalist said, the passage of the Letwin Amendment "may turn out to be little more than a stay of execution". I don't see how the Remain camp can turn the tide.

https://twitter.com/HouseofCommons/status/1185554322832138240
The only way to possibly break the current deadlock is through a general election. But the problem is that it could result in another hung Parliament.

Anyhow, so long as the pro-leave parties can't form a majority in the HoC, it's a win for the Remainers; whereas, If Boris succeeds in capturing the majority he craves, apparently that's the conclusion of the Brexit saga.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2019-50311003
“吃地沟油的命,操中南海的心”。
对于此语我倾向以思想自由为立足点进行反驳:“别人脑袋里怎么想你管得着吗?”
就算真相本身令人恐慌,但说出真相的人无罪,“令人恐慌”不是你怪罪揭露实情者的理由。
秋瑾和徐锡麟爱不爱国?
是,处死秋瑾和徐锡麟的人一定说他们不爱国。因为他们不爱大清,所以他们不爱国。然而后人谁不明白:他们不爱大清,正是因为他们爱中国。

关注某人是否“恨国”,不如关注他有无“祸国”。
“恨国”关注的是动机,可动机往往不能被确证。与其关注难得确证的动机,不如去关注“祸国”。问某人有没有祸国,实际是问其行动有无产生一种现实效果,而效果是可以被更明明白白衡量、确定的。甲某恨不恨国不好说,乙某祸不祸国却不难衡量,观察此人的行动是否使社会客观受害即可。

#天真地想要绕出现有框架
A. K. Rogers: "At the outset the sense of rights is no more than this inarticulate feeling that the presence in us of any strong desire forms a guarantee that somehow it ought to be met,—a feeling which leaves us with a sense of personal aggrievement in case the fulfillment does not take place. The sense of rebellion which stirs in me when I contemplate an invasion of my rights, is just this upheaval of my instincts against a force threatening to put restraint upon their freedom. The knowledge that I am being disregarded in other men's plans, the feeling of impotence when interests vital to me are held back simply because my fellows refuse to take me into account in their reckonings, will inevitably arouse in me a fierce resentment, which is the starting point of all my sense of rights."

From The Rights of Man, an article published in 1912. It can be found here.
片简拾零
A. K. Rogers: "At the outset the sense of rights is no more than this inarticulate feeling that the presence in us of any strong desire forms a guarantee that somehow it ought to be met,—a feeling which leaves us with a sense of personal aggrievement in case…
非常喜欢这段描写,对权利感萌芽时的心理有鲜活呈现。

不过作者随即指出,基于个体意欲而形成的权利感,易陷入一种唯我独尊、无视他人同等权利的境地。显然,要求享有一种权利,仅凭这种原初的权利感,尚不足以构成该诉求的全部正当性基础,还需要引入其它要素进行平衡。作者提及公平心和同情心,但感到在制衡人的唯我独尊、无视他人同样权利的冲动时,公平心和同情心并非普遍适用。

故而作者认为,要保证权利诉求的正当性,更可靠的路径是回归主张权利即主张妥协的理性思维,这就要求个体清醒地认知到自身很多时候注定无法得到绝对的满足,而且个体自身得到满足的前提是不排挤他人获得同样的满足。身处人类社会,可以说这无非是处世常识,因为每个人都为他人所环绕,每个人更都与他人互相依赖。

为使自身的权利感为他人所认可,唯有将其社会化,否则对权利的追求只会寸步难行。而所谓权利感社会化,即无论自己提出任何权利主张,其中均包含有对他人相同主张的尊重,让其他人亦可以此维护自己的利益。通过消除个人权利感潜在的排他性,以追求人权,而非追求特权,来获取他人的共鸣,减少阻力或达成合作。

易言之,个人的原初权利感需与理性的考量结合,从“这是我的权利”向“这是每一个人的权利”转变,自己要求享有的权利,也是其他社会成员同样能享有的。作者所言权利感的“社会化”,其义基本在此,前面的“要人权而非特权”之义也基本在此。
张之洞论阅洋报益处:

“然而吾谓报之益于人国者,博闻次也,知病上也。昔齐桓公不自知其有疾而死,秦以不闻其过而亡。大抵一国之利害安危,本国之人蔽于习俗,必不能尽知之,即知之亦不敢尽言之,惟出之邻国,又出之至强之国,故昌言而无忌。我国君臣上下果能览之而动心,怵之而改作,非中国之福哉?近人阅洋报者,见其诋訾中国不留馀地,比之醉人,比之朽物,议分裂、议争先,类无不拂然怒者,吾谓此何足怒耶?勤攻吾阙者,诸葛之所求;讳疾灭身者,周子之所痛。古云士有诤友,今虽云国有诤邻,不亦可乎?”

语见《劝学篇·外篇阅报第六》。自谓张香涛于书中力倡者无非洋务,不意尚能有此卓识。今人反不及之,掩目塞耳,陷溺于夸谈谬论,愈呈夜郎之态。为之叹息奈何。
[Note: After the media projected Biden to be the winner of the 2020 presidential race back in November, I wrote a few words to put down my feelings for this historic election. Now that electors in 50 states and D.C. have cast their ballots, the election result is all but set in stone. Thought this is the right moment to post them here.]

The United States is undergoing another tremendous trial. A trial it has not seen for decades. A trial the person who enters White House on January 20 as the 46th president must use every fiber of his/her being to overcome. At this difficult time, I feel so relieved to know that it will be Joe Biden to assume the mantle that has been passed down for more than two centuries. I wish him good health and success. Yet America's soul is still broken, and the future looks dim. With two crises at the same time, the pandemic and the resulting economic recession, even 4 years of his presidency is unlikely to restore the soul to its former place. No principle, ideal or conscience matters if many people continue to struggle amid hardship and uncertainty. The situation is much more dire than the one he and Obama faced in 2008. To lead his country back on the right track, Mr. Biden has a uphill battle to fight. From the bottom of my heart, I want him to win this battle. I want to see him succeed. I sincerely hope that posterity, rather than seeing Joe Biden as a guardian hopelessly defending the last citadel against a sea-change, will remember him as a pioneer laying the groundwork for better and brighter things to come in the future.
Quotes from The Expanse 506 & 510.