sheetposting – Telegram
sheetposting
852 subscribers
117K photos
34.3K videos
26 files
9.35K links
Download Telegram
“The project claims that the World ID will prove they are not robots”

Well no, obviously.

Individual level —

It doesn’t at all show that you didn’t simply hand over your authorization to a robot, to do whatever on your behalf. So at the individual level, no, it’s beyond useless at definitively proving this negative.

I.e. this CANNOT prove someone INNOCENT of using a robot.

Once they force everyone on OpenAI to authenticate through Worldcoin, though, then it could in help to prove the positive dual — i.e. proving it WAS you who used an AI to help you write that scathing article about some politician.

I.e. it CAN prove you GUILTY, but only if you’re not a sophisticated criminal.

= Can only hurt you, never help you, at an individual level.

Aggregate level —

Ok, so what about at the aggregate level, e.g. for preventing cheating for voting, product reviews, and the like?

Well, here it wouldn’t be totally useless in principle, as it creates a financial burden for a single entity to pretend to be multiple people, and rig a vote.

Only problem? That financial burden is already tiny, if not totally collapsed.

Black markets already showing that financial burden to have an upper-bound of maybe $4 per identity max, much cheaper if you rent, and the lower-bound on that is effectively zero, if any of several very easy hacks happen.

How for about proving OpenAI innocent or guilty? —

Nope. Can’t do that at all. The cost for them to rig this system against everyone else is, obviously, potentially $0. Hugely net-profitable even, in many cases.

So, what’s Worldcoin good for?

Helping the central powers,
while hurting you.
That’s it.