Plan with the swan?

Might be a silly question but did the others have a plan with what to do with the swan? They obviously knew about the swan and must’ve known about the button (the flame had that layout of the looking glass so they must’ve had info on the swan). Therefore, they’d know that whoever is down there wouldn’t be pushing the button forever (they knew about the pearl so I’m guessing they saw kelvin/radzinsky/desmond on the screen at some point).

The thought I have against them having any plan is Ben saying to John that he called the button a joke. Also it’s not like they were monitoring the swan from the pearl 24/7 to be ready if someone stopped pushing the button (Desmond didn’t push the button whenever oceanic 815 crashed and the others were freaking out at the barracks). What do y’all think?

https://redd.it/1pot0qe
@lostbackup

Jack's & Kate character

These two are the main characters of the show lol . Sorry not sorry but I did not like neither Jack's or Kate's character.
1) Jack was annoying to say the least and even though he was the main character of the show he really did not put much meaning to the entire series . The way we were told the back story of every character in the series , other characters made more sense and connected to the island that they could've been the main character of the show like Desmond , Daniel and Hurley.The show would've still worked out even without Jack. I used to like him in the starting of the first season but as the series progresses it's weird to see how he just wants everyone to follow his lead and he's really a bad listener and didn't listened to anyone else except him and later to Juliet . I have seen a lot of people rant about Kate and how she did dirty to Jack but wasn't it Jack who hardly respected her opinions and did what HE thought was right?
All in all I'm not saying that I hated him he was a kind person but he acted like he knows what to do but actually did messed up things until we reach to the end of the series .

2)Next Kate , I used to really like her in the first season and she had so much potential to be a baddie and hold a strong female character position but this girl only started gaf abt Jack and Sawyer and just couldn't decide who she wanted to be with . I really wish she was not surrounded by this only and had her own journey in lost . Everytime her past life was shown in the show I really like her in that but as soon as she had to act upon the situations on the island she sucked lmao .

Also Kate and Jack had no chemistry at all and they were polar opposites of each other so except for the part that they are the main characters of the show their pairing made no sense to me . I do not like any ships of Kate btw she deserved to be single and should've had her own journey instead of running around those two men .

Yep so this was my rant because I expected the main characters to be better than this but side characters did better than these two and that really might just be my opinion.

https://redd.it/1poxdw3
@lostbackup

About Watching Getting Lost

I have recently finished Lost. Great show and characters. Loved the journey and will stick with me for the rest of my life. I still have to watch the new man in charge, and then the documentary. That'll be it for new content sadly. I wanted to ask, for fans of the show, how good was the documentary, did it satisfy you guys, im hearing mixed thoughts. Usually documentaries aren't my thing so I dont want my Lost experience ruined.

THANKS G

https://redd.it/1pp54i9
@lostbackup

All the feels

So I’m rewatching lost for like the 12th time and every time I do it’s just so nostalgic! I really feel they nailed it with how creepy and intriguing it was. Especially in the first few seasons! The music GETS ME

Fave moments from watching season 1 again so far -
John Locke realises he can wiggle his toes
The first time season the ‘monster’ in the jungle
The transceiver picking up the French woman’s signal
When they find out Ethan was not on the manifest and jack and Locke go bolting through the jungle to find Charlie and Claire

What are your fave lost moments??




https://redd.it/1pp7yv4
@lostbackup

Question about Locke's ability to walk and the MiB

Hey, so in Season 1 we see Locke lose his ability to walk shortly before Boone has his accident. This is explained away as the island required a sacrifice - something that never seems to come back as a narrative device after that.

Some have speculated that the vision given to Locke the night before was manipulation from the MiB in hopes it would kill off one of the candidates. Is it also within the MiB's powers of manipulation to limit Locke's ability to walk?

The sacrifice thing just doesn't seem to jive with me now as much as it did 20 years ago. If the island needed a sacrifice, why is that never seemingly a thing afterwards?

https://redd.it/1pp7vrk
@lostbackup

How did MIB know that using the wheel would get him off the island?

So this is one of the many hang-ups I have about the history of the island which I don’t remember being explained by the end of the show. It really bothered me that the MIB said his wheel invention would get him off the island but it wasn’t explained WHY that would happen. I mean obviously he was right in a way, but was it just a lucky guess? Hoping that connecting to the “source” would get him what he wanted?

Don’t get me wrong I appreciate the value of showing and not telling, so I didn’t expect him to look at the camera and say “the source is going to do xyz and take me off the island”, but I feel like I missed some connecting dots somehow.

But also maybe I’m reading too into it. I’m someone who would love at least a half a season on the ancient island people soooooo I enjoy those details.

TIA for the discussion!

https://redd.it/1ppann6
@lostbackup

Spoiler Never being named annoyed me

I didn't like that they never gave the man in black a name.

That felt really silly to me on several levels.

What did Jacob and his mother call him for all those years? "Hey you" ? At some point wouldn't either of them have given him a name?

Why would the LOSTIE's keep referring to him as Locke once he got stuck in Locke's form? Jack literally says he's dishonoring his memory by wearing his meat suit, yet continues to call him Locke.

They could have called him the smoke monster, or ya know... asked him what his real name was.

My all time favorite show, but this always irked me.

https://redd.it/1ppbzt3
@lostbackup

Sayid and Shannon

Never really understood this pairing much. I get that he was encouraging for her and she was helpful for him, but does anyone have a deeper understanding of why they turned romantic? I can see more why Shannon would like him. Sayid was probably the first man to actually see her as more than a pretty face, but Sayid was going to LA to find Nadia and still had hope they would make it off the island. If Shannon hadn’t have died would he have just gave up on being with Nadia for her?

https://redd.it/1ppbsqq
@lostbackup

Do you think there’s been a TV promo in the last 15 years that rivalled the David LaChappelle spot for LOST?

https://youtu.be/4XBtWYBPTns?si=yyvlZGLTmzZBSveh

https://redd.it/1pp7a2s
@lostbackup

What's your favorite music?

Dear LOST community,

it's been a year and a half since I've had the (sadly limited) pleasure of discovering my favorite show for the first time.

I've been waiting patiently since then, to wait for the right time to rewatch the show.

Ever since then, i've wondered about all the reasons we love the show to this degree.

And on one of those times of thinking, a question came upon me, that i wish to ask you all:

What's your favorite music (of the show & in general)?

What i enjoyed about the show, was the importance of the music and the soundtrack and how it reflected the themes and topics in it. (The intro is so short, yet so mesmerizing and REAL)

And i've wondered what kind of music you folks have been attracted to, that gave a similar sense of empowerment as this show has given you.

My favorite piece of music, that gave me an eeriely similar vibe to the show is "th1 evnslower" by Aphex Twin. I highly, highly recommend that you listen to it, because it certainly did take me back to the island lol.

With all that being said,

i really look forward to hearing what music you enjoy. Cheers.



https://redd.it/1ppdl4c
@lostbackup

Mile's inconsistent powers

Sorry if thsi has been talked to death already

It always bothered me that in Season 5 (Some Like it Hoth) Miles not only claims that he needs a body to get the memories of the dead, but that that's all that is happening and it has nothing to do with ghosts. He doesn't even beleive Hurly at first when he says he's been talking to dead people for this reason, and idsmisses the idea of ghosts existing entirely if I'm remembering correctly.

But in his introduction in Season 4, Miles has a real interaction with a ghost, talking to it in a way that makes it clear that he beleives he's talking to an actual ghost, and watching it actually lightly interact with the physichal world to show him where some money was hidden in the room.

It's not the worst retcon ever, but it doesn't make any sense and I think that it's bad enough that there's no rationalizing it. He clearly belives that he's talking to a ghost in that scene.

I've seen a couple people point out that his powers were slightly retconned with needing a body to get mempries, but this is a much bigger retcon with big implications for the nature of his powers and how he should view the universe. It's not just a minor thing

https://redd.it/1pph2xj
@lostbackup

Annoyed By Calling Alex Ben's Daughter

Just watched the whole series all the way through for the first time.

Why does the show insist on referring to Alex as Ben's daughter til the end, even after we learn he just brutally kidnapped her? Sure, he didn't abuse her, but it was otherwise nothing but a cruel, pointless act, and the show whitewashed her mother out after the 4th season.

https://redd.it/1ppigyc
@lostbackup

Re-watch the Lost series

I'm debating on re-watching the Lost series 🤔 seeing all you guys post kinda makes me want to watch it again but I've seen it like 3 or 4 times already which they'd make another series just as good Lost was a great one and I really enjoyed it when it came out

https://redd.it/1pphrus
@lostbackup

Thoughts after rewatching the pilot

Okay, so I evidently needed to rewatch the show once again based on how frequently I come to this sub lol this will be the third time I watch the show overall. I first started it almost 20 (!) years ago, in 2006. I decided to post some things that struck me about the first two episodes, popular and unpopular I’m sure just for funsies.

\- Kate really owned the hell out of that pilot, for me. And I’m biased, because she actually is my favorite character in the show. But I absolutely love how in the action she is, and gosh, Evangeline Lilly displayed so much range just in these episodes alone. It’s really impressive, especially considering how inexperienced she was at the time.

\- I also love the feeling of seeing how everything starts, and how the writers planted the seeds for the show’s mythology, and mainly for what would be unfolding in the next episodes of that first season. I also love the thriller/mystery aspect of this first season and how much exploring they have to do. It’s fun!

\- Jin and Sawyer were such assholes, omg. I know they get better but it doesn’t make me any less annoyed at them. But they look so good too lol

\- Speaking of looking good, there’s Sayid. I am so excited to rewatch more of him, because I really love him. It does upset me a little because I think they messed his character up a bit around season 6, which is unfortunate. I also know Naveen was a little done with the show around season 3, which makes me think that maybe they should’ve axed him around then while he was still peaking. But then we’d miss him shooting young Ben which for me is one of the greatest moments of the show because it illustrates how messed up he was emotionally and psychologically at that point.

\- Shannon deserved SO MUCH BETTER. And not just in a “in the story” type of way. I really think they dropped the ball with her and didn’t realize how much potential she had. I personally would’ve killed Charlie or Hurley instead of her since they wanted that friction between the two groups on season 2, if that meant she’d be on the show longer. If Sayid stayed on the island and she came back for him, that could be cool too.

\- Some scenes were beautifully shot, in an almost cinematic way, which I really appreciate. Like Locke sitting on the beach before it starts raining, Rose and Claire under the airplane debris while Smokey terrorizes the survivors... super cool to see.

\- Also love that MIB decided to fuck around that first night just because he could LMAO he really was excited about having all the girlies over and said “let me show off a little”, and him killing the pilot? Diabolical.

\- I understand the Marshall was doing his job but also why are you so obsessed with Kate??? like the first thing he does after waking up is asking where she is??? Yeah, he needs to go.

\- Also sad that we didn’t get to see the Michael/Walt relationship flourish as much as it could’ve. I never got really invested in their story, but for some reason it all kinda clicked tonight and I’m excited to track it this time, since they have some great moments on season 1. And for some reason, as awful/shocking as it is, and as much as it made me mad at Michael when it first happened, this time I was like... “yeah, I get why you did what you did on season 2”. I think that if I were as desperate as he was and afraid of losing a loved one (again), I probably would have done the same. And yes, I’d also be consumed by guilt as he did. But that was his son, after all.

\- Although there were definitely some gratuitous shots of the women in underwear, and the clear writing problems that we all know of, I still think that Lost had some pretty three-dimensional female characters with good well-written moments that still hold their own in these days??? Which unfortunately says a lot about our times. In terms of race + ethnicity representation, it gets way muddier, I think the diversity was great but they definitely should’ve had more BIPOCs in the writer’s room.

\- I also love how much air there was in this episode,

and in the show overall (especially the first seasons). They take their time to develop characters, introduce the story. So different than how it is nowadays. They didn’t underline everything all the time. So much better. And so refreshing to see how much they all look... normal? Which is wild to say considering that most of them were incredibly attractive and hot, but like... no fillers, no guy is insanely ripped in a way that one can only be if they take steroids... again, wild to say that since they all fit the beauty standards at the time, but very refreshing.

Anyway, super excited to continue! I’m already looking forward to watching some episodes, making some connections, realizing new stuff... and already dreading watching some of these flashbacks 💀

https://redd.it/1ppjx0a
@lostbackup

What story-line do you feel more annoyed that they didn't continue

What thing, it van be storyline character that they killed off yo early do you feel most annoyed with the screen writers because they didn't continue

This is my top 3
1 Aaron story line they had a lot of flashbacks telling Claire that she had to be the one to raise him and nothing else later, like literally nothing bad happened to Kate

2 this is very common, the Walt story that ended because he was growing to fast

3the libby in the psicyatrist that literally was never mentioned again and never poped out, I have seen somewhere that it was the actress had a meltdown or something but if someone could confirm it would be great

https://redd.it/1ppl2cb
@lostbackup

Long seasons allowed this show to be great

We are in the era of 10 episode seasons of TV (sometimes just 8) and the fact that LOST has multiple seasons of 20+ episodes allowed this show to have, in my opinion, the greatest character development ever. I grew to understand everyone’s past, characters that I hated - i learned to love and so forth.

I watch shows now am just frustrated with the 10 episode standard format because I want more development. I still consider it my favorite show of all time.

https://redd.it/1pplk86
@lostbackup

Well. Here we go.

I’m on my third watch, and the whole show gets more enjoyable every time, but Season 5 is particularly incredible.

For one thing, I was reading a bunch of Juliet love the other day, and I was like “Ew, really?” But when she said “Well. Here we go.” I 100% flipped. And I remember remembering the second time through how cool she is when she had a life and a love! And then she’s pretty much all dialogue bangers. I hate her breaking up with Sawyer, but it’s so different from her original icy demeanor that it’s really interesting, and retroactively puts her as an imprisoned kidnapping victim in a different context.

Hurley is brilliant, I can’t think of a specific to rave about, but who he is once he’s back on the island is so good.

Showing the scene where Jack’s dad tells him to count to five slipped under my radar before, but thinking about him altering the story when he told it to Kate, incredibly soon to waking up from the crash of the plane he was taking his father’s body on is so Jack, in a way no one (probably not even the writers) knew him to be at the time. Like, yeah, there’s the thing we know well about his anger at Christian, so not mentioning him makes sense.

But the absolute fucking ego on that guy to give himself credit for what he makes out to be a wise, courageous, inspiring idea. As always, he’s making himself the hero of the story. He uses his self-assigned savior status to get hero shit done, often, and his drive to save people makes him seem like a simple white hat early. But to what degree is that really about his ego?

https://redd.it/1ppq6t9
@lostbackup

Does anyone have ideas on the relevance of this photo on the monks desk in "Catch-22" s3e17?
https://redd.it/1ppr6ph
@lostbackup

The moment I got hooked
https://redd.it/1ppshvg
@lostbackup

Lost 3x23 (I still get chills)
https://redd.it/1pps5kf
@lostbackup